In the weeks before and after San Francisco's November election, I attended two panels exploring the role of money in SF politics. Hearing journalists from Mission Local and SF Standard discuss the candidates and ballot measures before and after the votes were counted helped me understand what it takes to win an election (and it's more than just money).

The “Money in Politics” Event at KALW

In late September, I went to the KALW (an NPR member station) live event space at 220 Montgomery for the “Money in Politics” event. At the September event, Mission Local’s Joe Eskenazi and data reporter Kelly Waldron followed the money involved in influencing the election and explained why San Francisco’s November election was mostly already decided.

Eskenazi explained that Mayor Daniel Lurie was more popular than ever due to improving the "curb appeal" of San Francisco. The enormous campaign spending backing his agenda meant he would be able to consolidate mayoral power with the passage of Propositions D, E, and F. Likewise, Scott Wiener had a massive fundraising advantage over Connie Chan in the CA-11 race. The takeaway was that money would buy the election, and that Lurie’s opponents lacked the resources to stop it.

KALW + Mission Local “Money In Politics” Event @ 220 Montgomery, Photo: FoglineSF

What Happened On Election Day

The morning after Election Day, my social media feeds were filled with hot takes about how billionaires had bought San Francisco. I even saw some posts repeating the false claim that SF voters had rejected California’s billionaire wealth tax.

But San Francisco voters actually supported Proposition 40, even though it lost statewide. The city also passed Prop B, which laid the foundation for a municipal public bank despite little funding for it. These results don't fit neatly into the narrative that wealthy donors can simply buy the results they want in SF’s elections.

In the rest of the country, money clearly didn’t buy the election either. The “blue tsunami” nationwide showed that even Elon Musk, the world’s richest man, couldn't buy whatever he wanted. And just last year, billionaire Bill Ackman and Wall Street CEOs spent over $40 million trying to defeat Zohran Mamdani in New York only to lose to a candidate with a clear message that resonated with voters. So money is powerful, but it isn’t everything.

Bay Area Election Results Event at KALW

After the full election results came in, I returned to KALW on November 11 to hear Eskenazi and SF Standard’s Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez dissect the results. My biggest takeaway was that money is able to amplify a message, but the message still needs to resonate with voters.

KALW + SF Standard “Bay Area Election: What It All Means” @ KALW, Photo: FoglineSF

Eskenazi explained that Wiener didn't beat Chan only because of his spending edge. He was simply "a stronger candidate with much more money and a much broader appeal." He had a clear urbanist platform, a focus on housing and transit, and a long legislative record. Chan, on the other hand, had trouble juggling the priorities of her different supporters and was “asked to do too much.” Her opposition to car-free JFK Drive and Sunset Dunes wasn’t going to win over any of the urbanist voters (Proposition G was overwhelmingly rejected by voters).

Having attended three debates between the candidates ourselves, our impression was that Chan spent more time explaining what she opposed than articulating a clear vision of what she would accomplish if elected.

The “Urbanist Middle”

If you look at neighborhood voting patterns, Chan won the Mission by a small margin, but Wiener won Haight-Ashbury with roughly 60% of the vote and Bernal Heights with 52%.

I learned that in 2024 the San Francisco Chronicle identified a voting bloc it calls the "Urbanist Middle", which includes neighborhoods like the Castro, Noe Valley, and Inner Richmond. The voters in these districts don't fit neatly into a “progressive” or “moderate” box. These voters support housing construction, improved public transit, car-free spaces, and other urbanist policies while remaining socially liberal.

During the KALW panel, Eskenazi explained that early YIMBY politicians were often too polarizing to win elections, but their ideas gradually became mainstream. So Wiener's victory might be a reflection of a shift in the electorate rather than simply a victory of wealthy donors. It seems entirely possible that voters can support taxing billionaires while also wanting more housing, better transit, and car-free public spaces.

Where Do We Go From Here?

San Francisco's political coalitions and demographics are changing and progressives can't simply blame their losses on being outspent. Despite their financial advantages, Lurie and Wiener aren't exactly unbeatable political superstars. As the KALW panelists pointed out, Wiener isn't particularly charismatic, and Lurie’s appeal comes mostly from his friendly persona and optimistic messaging. But both of them have messages that resonate with voters. What if money wasn't the only reason their opponents lost? What if those opponents simply failed to offer voters a compelling alternative?

Lurie has been winning with a simple message of "Let's Go San Francisco." The money makes sure that people hear his message, but his popularity shows that many voters believe in his message too. Both KALW panels raised the question of how long Lurie’s popularity can last. San Francisco is still extremely expensive, and if residents don't see big improvements in affordability, "Let's Go San Francisco" will increasingly become a sarcastic punchline (another trend I’m noticing on social media).

My biggest takeaway from the two panels was that while money can buy advertising, consultants, and political influence, San Franciscans aren't passive consumers who automatically vote the way billionaires tell them to. Candidates still need a message voters believe in and eventually they need to deliver on it.